Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (2024)

Table of Contents
57. 2022 Los Angeles Rams 56. 1982 San Francisco 49ers 55. 1981 Oakland Raiders 54. 2013 Baltimore Ravens 53. 1999 Denver Broncos 52. 1991 New York Giants 51. 1988 Washington 50. 2006 Pittsburgh Steelers 49. 1968 Green Bay Packers 48. 2003 Tampa Bay Buccaneers 47. 2016 Denver Broncos 46. 1987 New York Giants 45. 2012 New York Giants 44. 2009 Pittsburgh Steelers 43. 1980 Pittsburgh Steelers 42. 1970 Kansas City Chiefs 41. 2002 New England Patriots 40. 2001 Baltimore Ravens 39. 2018 Philadelphia Eagles 38. 1992 Washington 37. 2005 New England Patriots 36. 1996 Dallas Cowboys 35. 2019 New England Patriots 34. 1969 New York Jets 33. 1984 Los Angeles Raiders 32. 2010 New Orleans Saints 31. 2000 St. Louis Rams 30. 1985 San Francisco 49ers 29. 2021 Tampa Bay Buccaneers 28. 1972 Dallas Cowboys 27. 1971 Baltimore Colts 26. 2008 New York Giants 25. 2017 New England Patriots 24. 2015 New England Patriots 23. 1995 San Francisco 49ers 22. 1977 Oakland Raiders 21. 1974 Miami Dolphins 20. 1994 Dallas Cowboys 19. 2011 Green Bay Packers 18. 2007 Indianapolis Colts 17. 2020 Kansas City Chiefs 16. 1983 Washington 15. 1978 Dallas Cowboys 14. 1986 Chicago Bears 13. 2014 Seattle Seahawks 12. 1990 San Francisco 49ers 11. 1997 Green Bay Packers 10. 2023 Kansas City Chiefs 9. 1967 Green Bay Packers 8. 1979 Pittsburgh Steelers 7. 1976 Pittsburgh Steelers 6. 1993 Dallas Cowboys 5. 2004 New England Patriots 4. 1998 Denver Broncos 3. 1975 Pittsburgh Steelers 2. 1973 Miami Dolphins 1. 1989 San Francisco 49ers

1 of 57

57. 2022 Los Angeles Rams

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (1)

Jayne Kamin-Oncea-USA TODAY Sports

While the extensions for Matthew Stafford, Cooper Kupp and Aaron Donald produced a recovery, the immediate return on those deals created a new tier for Super Bowl title defenses. The Rams went 5-12; no other defending champ had lost 11 games. This season's final third came without Donald, Kupp or Stafford due to injuries, but the Rams buried themselves earlier. O-line trouble persisted, and trade pushes for Christian McCaffrey and Brian Burns failed. This strange season did produce some Baker Mayfield fun, after the waiver claim led a 98-yard game-winning drive despite being on the team three days. Sean McVay considered leaving the Rams in 2023 but rejuvenated the team upon returning.

2 of 57

56. 1982 San Francisco 49ers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (2)

Michael Zagaris-Getty Images

The 49ers followed up their 1981 emergence with an odd journey back toward the NFL's basem*nt. San Francisco's first Super Bowl title defense came in a strike-shortened season, and it failed to come close to meeting expectations. Joe Montana started all nine games in 1982, and his storied partner on "The Catch," Dwight Clark, was an All-Pro. The 49ers still went 3-6. Their defense plummeted from second in points allowed in '81 to 23rd a year later. Bill Walsh's injury-plagued team lost its first two games, before the strike, and did not have as much time to recover when play resumed in November.

3 of 57

55. 1981 Oakland Raiders

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (3)

Focus on Sport-Getty Images

Just ahead of their first awkward Oakland exit, the 1981 Raiders finished 7-9 and suddenly had a quarterback controversy. Despite Jim Plunkett leading Oakland to the Super Bowl XV title, he started for the Raiders in three straight shutout losses early in the '81 season. Tom Flores (and Al Davis, essentially) benched Plunkett and went with 1980 first-round pick Marc Wilson, who never found his footing in the NFL. Oakland's offense ranked 25th. Plunkett eventually regained his job and led the Los Angeles Raiders to a Super Bowl title three years later.

4 of 57

54. 2013 Baltimore Ravens

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (4)

Patrick Smith-Getty Images

An Orioles game prevented the Ravens from the customary post-Super Bowl Thursday home game, and the result set a bad tone for the season. Peyton Manning shredded the Ravens for an NFL-record seven touchdown passes in Denver, and the defending champs slogged through an unremarkable 8-8 slate. Joe Flacco threw 22 interceptions — by far a career-worst mark — and three-time Pro Bowler Ray Rice averaged only 3.1 yards per carry in what became his final season. The Ravens had playoff hopes in December, when a four-game win streak included a rapid-fire Vikings shootout, but were blown out by the Patriots and Bengals to close the year.

5 of 57

53. 1999 Denver Broncos

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (5)

Brian Bahr-Getty Images

John Elway's May 1999 retirement left the Broncos in big trouble, and Mike Shanahan opted for untested second-year quarterback Brian Griese over veteran backup Bubby Brister. The two-time defending champions lost reigning league MVP Terrell Davis and fellow future Hall of Famer Shannon Sharpe to season-ending injuries early. Davis never recovered fully from his severe knee malady, and an 0-4 start buried the Broncos. They finished 6-10 — the standard for most losses for a defending Super Bowl champion until the 2022 Rams emerged — but lost eight of those games by one score and were just minus-4 in point differential.

6 of 57

52. 1991 New York Giants

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (6)

Focus on Sport-Getty Images

Losing a Hall of Fame coach and a future Hall of Fame assistant, the 1991 Giants were a freefall candidate from the start. The aftermath of Bill Parcells' initial retirement and defensive coordinator Bill Belichick's relocation to Cleveland was uneventful. New York went 8-8 under overmatched head coach Ray Handley, who was fired after the 1992 season, and lost its defensive muscle following Belichick's departure. The Giants inexplicably played longtime backup Jeff Hostetler over Phil Simms for much of the season. Handley never coached again after his dismissal.

7 of 57

51. 1988 Washington

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (7)

Jonathan Daniel-Getty Images

The most unique of the 1980s-'90s NFC powers, Washington won Super Bowls with three different starting quarterbacks. The transition from No. 2 (Doug Williams) to No. 3 (Mark Rypien) began in 1988. Joe Gibbs benched Williams for Rypien, whose full-time starting run lasted until 1993. A severe injury to running back Kelvin Bryant, and Timmy Smith being unable to replicate his Super Bowl rushing-record form doomed Washington's run game. Its defense also ranked as the NFL's third-worst unit. Washington went 7-9 but bounced back soon after. Several starters from this team were around for the franchise's 1991 Super Bowl return.

8 of 57

50. 2006 Pittsburgh Steelers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (8)

Glenn Asakawa-The Denver Post via Getty Images

Ben Roethlisberger's offseason included a motorcycle crash and an appendectomy, and the Steelers could not get right either. Their top-tier Super Bowl defense regressed to 11th in '06, and Big Ben finished with 18 touchdown passes and a league-high 23 interceptions. Pittsburgh started 2-6 and could not recover in an 8-8 season. Bill Cowher retired after the season, but the Steelers rebounded quickly under Mike Tomlin — making the playoffs in 2007 and winning their sixth Super Bowl a year later.

9 of 57

49. 1968 Green Bay Packers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (9)

Focus on Sport-Getty Images

Vince Lombardi stayed on as Packers general manager, after retiring following Super Bowl II, but the nucleus he built years prior was aging could not stay its nearly unparalleled course. Following a run of three straight NFL championships, the 1968 Packers went 6-7-1 under new coach Phil Bengtson. The '68 team still had Hall of Famers Bart Starr, Ray Nitschke, Herb Adderley, Willie Wood, Forrest Gregg, Henry Jordan and Jerry Kramer. But this season officially concluded Green Bay's 1960s dynasty.

10 of 57

48. 2003 Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (10)

Eliot J. Schechter-Getty Images

Two years before the Eagles effectively kicked Terrell Owens off the team, the Buccaneers set up a blueprint with a disgruntled Keyshawn Johnson. A diva wideout before Owens, Randy Moss and future Buccaneer Antonio Brown took the label to the next level, Johnson played 10 games with the Bucs that season — his last in Tampa. The '03 Bucs went 7-9, and though they still carried a top-level defense, it could not match the Super Bowl unit's all-time dominance. Jon Gruden coached the Bucs until 2008 and returned to the Raiders in 2018, but Super Bowl XXXVII remains his most recent playoff win.

11 of 57

47. 2016 Denver Broncos

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (11)

Jake Roth-USA TODAY Sports

The Broncos have a stranglehold on quarterbacks going out on a high note. John Elway and Peyton Manning are the only two to ever do it. Their Manning successor was far more obscure than Elway's. Trevor Siemian became easily the most random quarterback given the keys to a Super Bowl title defense. The Northwestern alum fared OK, given his seventh-round pedigree, but the Broncos' struggles on offense and run defense doomed them. Von Miller, Chris Harris and Aqib Talib earned All-Pro honors for a historically dominant pass defense that nearly dragged Denver (9-7) to the playoffs. QB issues worsened for the Broncos in the years that followed.

12 of 57

46. 1987 New York Giants

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (12)

George Gojkovich-Getty Images

While the 1987 players' strike ignited Washington to a Super Bowl title (and loosely inspired 2000's "The Replacements"), it doomed the defending champions' season. Already 0-2 prior to the strike, the Giants saw their replacement squad dig the regulars an 0-5 hole. The team ended up 6-9. Bill Parcells said this turn of events still bothers him. Standout tight end Mark Bavaro did at least earn All-Pro acclaim in this lost season. The Giants missed the playoffs in 1988 before rerouting their operation and winning Super Bowl XXV to close out the Parcells era in 1990.

13 of 57

45. 2012 New York Giants

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (13)

Patrick McDermott-Getty Images

Football Outsiders' DVOA metric rated the 2012 Giants as better than the 2011 version. But the '11 team had a chance to come together in the playoffs. The '12 Giants were not as explosive offensively. Victor Cruz still played well but never again resembled his dominant 2011 self, and Hakeem Nicks began to see injuries lead to an early career conclusion. After the 2011 team's NASCAR package stormed Tom Brady and Co. in Super Bowl XLVI, no Giant registered more than 6.5 sacks in 2012. Blowout December defeats to the Falcons and Ravens ended Big Blue's repeat hopes. They finished 9-7.

14 of 57

44. 2009 Pittsburgh Steelers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (14)

David Eulitt/Kansas City Star via Getty Images

The modern-era Steelers champions have not produced successful encores. After the 2008 team fielded an all-time defense, the '09 version finished 12th in points allowed. A knee injury limited Troy Polamalu to five games. Ben Roethlisberger located Hines Ward and Santonio Holmes often (2,465 combined air yards), and running back Rashard Mendenhall broke out in Year 2. But the Steelers went 9-7, doomed by a five-game late-season losing streak that included losses to the four-win Chiefs and five-win Browns. Mike Tomlin's next squad, with its defensive mojo back, voyaged to Super Bowl XLV.

15 of 57

43. 1980 Pittsburgh Steelers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (15)

Focus on Sport-Getty Images

Age caught up with the Steelers in the early 1980s. Eleven of their starters entered the 1980 season north of 30, and the once-vaunted Steel Curtain was now a middling defense. John Stallworth missed 13 games, and Lynn Swann was the Steelers' third-leading receiver. Swann retired after the 1983 season. This Pittsburgh iteration went 9-7 and finished behind the Browns and Oilers in the AFC Central. The Steelers recovered to make the 1984 AFC championship game, but most of the '70s stalwarts were gone by then.

16 of 57

42. 1970 Kansas City Chiefs

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (16)

Charles Aqua Viva-Getty Images

The Chiefs' first year in the NFL did not go too well. The Vikings exacted revenge for Super Bowl IV with a 27-10 Week 1 win, beginning a hangover season in Kansas City. Other than the unearthing of running back Ed Podolak, a rookie backup in 1969, little went well for a Chiefs offense that ranked 15th. Kansas City couldn't reignite its team — one that still had seven Hall of Famers — and finished 7-5-2. The Chiefs rebounded in 1971, returning to the playoffs for a marathon battle with the Dolphins, but then hit nearly two decades' worth of tough sledding until Marty Schottenheimer's arrival.

17 of 57

41. 2002 New England Patriots

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (17)

Matthew J. Lee-The Boston Globe via Getty Images

The initial Patriots title defense sputtered. This was the last time New England missed the playoffs with a healthy Tom Brady. The 2002 season marked the Pats' worst defensive performance (17th in scoring) in the Brady-Bill Belichick partnership's 20 seasons. Brady failed to make the Pro Bowl, while predecessor Drew Bledsoe —whom Belichick traded to Buffalo that April — made his fourth. New England lost two of its final three games and finished 9-7, allowing Miami to win the division. The Patriots won the next two Super Bowls and 16 of the next 17 AFC East titles. Good turnaround.

18 of 57

40. 2001 Baltimore Ravens

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (18)

Andy Lyons-Getty Images

After a storied defense carried a Trent Dilfer-piloted offense to a Super Bowl title, the Ravens' follow-up (the "Hard Knocks" guinea pig) signaled this imbalance wasn't going away. Baltimore ditched Dilfer for Elvis Grbac, who threw 15 TD passes and 21 INTs before retiring at season's end. (A Brad Johnson free agency pursuit failed.) The defense-fueled Ravens went 10-6 but lost twice to the woeful Browns — in their third season post-reboot. After a Ravens wild-card win in Miami, the Steelers easily handled their rivals, 27-10. Grbac threw three picks in that loss. Baltimore did not win another playoff game until Joe Flacco's rookie year.

19 of 57

39. 2018 Philadelphia Eagles

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (19)

Bill Streicher-USA TODAY Sports

The Eagles' first Super Bowl title defense underwhelmed. Philadelphia went 9-7 and did not rank in the top 12 in scoring offense or defense. Carson Wentz's starts produced a 5-6 record, and the 2017 MVP frontrunner saw another season end early due to injury. Nick Foles steered a rescue effort, piloting Philly to three December wins — one over the NFC champion Rams in Los Angeles — and a playoff berth. This resurgent team won the "Double Doink" game in Chicago and had the Saints on the ropes in Round 2. The franchise sailed through rough waters for a bit, but it collected a first-round pick in the Wentz trade and rebuilt rapidly. Some of the Super Bowl LII regulars made the trip back to the big stage five years later.

20 of 57

38. 1992 Washington

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (20)

Focus on Sport-Getty Images

A case can be made for Washington's 1991 team as a Mt. Rushmore NFL squad. Joe Gibbs 1.0's finale in '92, however, was not as laudable. Although Washington beat the eventual Super Bowl champion Cowboys, it went 9-7 and ranked 14th in points (a year after the '91 powerhouse led the league). Mark Rypien's acclaimed wideouts (Art Monk, Gary Clark and Ricky Sanders -- "The Posse") were all over 30 by now and none eclipsed 1,000 yards for the first time since 1983. After a wild-card win in Minnesota, Washington lost to the No. 1-seeded 49ers a week later. This turned out to end an era. Washington, which soon went through a notable ownership change, has not made consecutive playoff berths since.

21 of 57

37. 2005 New England Patriots

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (21)

Mike Ehrmann-Getty Images

After going a preposterous 28-4 between the 2003-04 seasons, the Patriots regressed in their three-peat bid. Tom Brady in Year 6 was still not yet on his prodigious level, and Belichick — who has deployed 18 top-10 defenses since 2001 — did not coax his usual stoppage success (17th) in '05. The Pats lost four games by double digits and went 10-6. They beat the Jaguars handily in Round 1 but saw Champ Bailey's 100-yard INT return, whichfeatured an unusual conclusion, represent one of five turnovers in the Broncos' 27-13 divisional-round win — the Belichick-Brady era's first playoff blemish.

22 of 57

36. 1996 Dallas Cowboys

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (22)

Sporting News via Getty Images

The last of the 1990s' quality Cowboy teams, this one went 10-6 and showed signs of decline. Emmitt Smith averaged a Cowboys-years-low 3.7 yards per carry and did not make the Pro Bowl despite scoring 15 TDs. Dallas' offense ranked 25th, after boasting the No. 3 attack during Barry Switzer's Super Bowl season, and Troy Aikman threw just 12 TD passes. The Cowboys did beat the Super Bowl champion Packers and mustered a final playoff salvo — a 40-15 first-round win over the Vikings. But they lost to the second-year Panthers in Round 2 during a game in which Michael Irvin suffered an opening-drive injury. This season began Dallas' streak of divisional-round shortcomings.

23 of 57

35. 2019 New England Patriots

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (23)

Winslow Townson-USA TODAY Sports

Despite starting 8-0 and fielding a No. 1 defense, this team became the rare Patriot outfit to fold in high-stakes situations. The 12-4 Pats padded their plus-195 differential against a favorable schedule, facing multiple rebuilding AFC East teams, the 2-14 Bengals and a historicallybad NFC East quartet. Tom Brady struggled during Rob Gronkowski's WWE sabbatical, and the team's big-name receiver shuffle (from Antonio Brown to Josh Gordon to Mohamed Sanu) produced little of consequence. The understaffed Dolphins' Week 17 upset preceded a Round 1 loss to the Titans. Brady (feat. Gronk) then left for Tampa and won ring No. 7.

24 of 57

34. 1969 New York Jets

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (24)

Focus On Sport-Getty Images

A year after pulling off one of sports' iconic upsets, the Jets went 10-4 and won the AFL East division in the league's final season. However, 1969 produced an expanded four-team playoff format. Instead of division winners meeting for the AFL crown, they needed to navigate wild-card teams. The 11-3 Chiefs, a wild card, edged the Jets in a 13-6 opening-round win, beating the defending Super Bowl champs for a second time that year en route to their Super Bowl IV victory. This was the Joe Namath era's final playoff game; New York did not return to the postseason until 1981.

25 of 57

33. 1984 Los Angeles Raiders

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (25)

Focus on Sport-Getty Images

Fresh off his Super Bowl MVP showing, Marcus Allen churned out another dominant season. The Los Angeles native amassed 1,926 scrimmage yards and scored 18 touchdowns. Allen's TD total bettered Eric Dickerson's mark in his rushing-record campaign. The Raiders ranked fourth defensively but performed more QB shuffling. Los Angeles gave Marc Wilson a long look after a Jim Plunkett injury but went back to the veteran before its playoff opener. The 11-5 team beat the AFC champion Dolphins but had to trek to Seattle for a wild-card date. The Seahawks exacted revenge for the previous year's AFC title game, beating the Raiders 13-7.

26 of 57

32. 2010 New Orleans Saints

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (26)

Jonathan Ferrey-Getty Images

One of the best Saints defenses in the Drew Brees era endured a rough night that has been difficult to escape. The 2010 Saints ranked seventh in scoring defense. They beat both the AFC champion Steelers and the NFC's top seed, the Falcons, in the regular season. But NFL rules mandated their 11-5 squad travel to face a 7-9 team in the playoffs. The Seahawks' 12th Man went mainstream that night, unfortunately for the Saints. Matt Hasselbeck outdueled Brees, and Marshawn Lynch's "Beastquake" run catapulted Seattle to a 41-36 win. Several painful Saints playoff losses followed over the next decade.

27 of 57

31. 2000 St. Louis Rams

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (27)

Joseph Patronite-Getty Images

These Rams rocketed to a 6-0 start behind reigning MVP Kurt Warner, who threw 17 TD passes in that span, and eventual MVP Marshall Faulk (then-record 26 TDs in 2000). Warner then broke a finger on his throwing hand in Week 7, and the Rams — their No. 1 offense held down by the last-ranked defense — went just 2-3 while Trent Green (back from his 1999 ACL tear) filled in for Warner. Mike Martz's first Rams team edged the Saints in Week 17 to make the playoffs at 10-6. However, an Az Hakim muffed punt deprived the league's No. 1 offense from a game-winning drive chance in a Round 1 rematch in New Orleans. The Rams improved on defense to win the NFC in 2001.

28 of 57

30. 1985 San Francisco 49ers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (28)

Ronald C. Modra/Sports Imagery/Getty Images

This was a forgettable 49ers team, illustrating their dynasty's firepower. The 49ers routed the NFC West champion Rams and the AFC's top seed, the Raiders, but much like their 1988 Super Bowl team, they were inconsistent. This year is best known for Roger Craig's trailblazing 1,000-1,000 season, Jerry Rice's shaky rookie showing and the injury that induced Ronnie Lott to partially amputate a finger. Joe Montana still threw 27 touchdown passes, just three to the future wide receiver deity, and guided the 49ers to a 10-6 record. The Giants beat the 49ers 10-7 in a wild-card game. Big Blue eliminated the '86 49ers as well.

29 of 57

29. 2021 Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (29)

Matt Pendleton-USA TODAY Sports

Bucs management greenlit the 2020 champion core returning en masse, separating this title defense from every other post-merger effort. Injuries wrecked the plan. Well, injuries and Antonio Brown predictably burning the Bucs for misguided faith. Tampa Bay went 13-4, and its plus-158 point differential outdid the Super Bowl-winning team's mark. Tom Brady remained near his top form at 44, but Brown's mania and Chris Godwin's ACL tear proved too much to overcome — especially as O-linemen started dropping in the playoffs. The Rams nearly handed the Bucs a mystifying divisional-round victory but avoided a collapse en route to a title. Brady then retired, unretired and re-retired after an 8-9 2022 slate.

30 of 57

28. 1972 Dallas Cowboys

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (30)

James Flores-Getty Images

These Cowboys made it to the NFC championship game without Roger Staubach getting a start. The starter during Dallas' 1971 Super Bowl stretch run separated his shoulder months later and did not get his job back upon return. Craig Morton, whom Staubach usurped in '71, started throughout the year. The Cowboys went 10-4, but the future Hall of Fame QB came off the bench in the fourth quarter of a divisional-round game to lead a 15-point fourth-quarter comeback and stun the 49ers. Washington blew out Dallas a week later, but Staubach's job security was never again threatened.

31 of 57

27. 1971 Baltimore Colts

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (31)

Focus on Sport/Getty Images

Carried by a defensive unit that yielded just 10 points per game, the Colts extended their Super Bowl V title defense into the following year's AFC championship game. A 38-year-old Johnny Unitas and 37-year-old Earl Morrall split the snaps in the regular season — a 10-4 Colts showing — before Unitas won his final playoff game, helping Baltimore to a 20-3 win over Cleveland. Unitas threw three INTs in what would be his last postseason appearance — a 21-0 loss to the Dolphins and former Colts coach Don Shula. Morrall soon joined his old coach in Miami and played a key role on the Dolphins' perfect 1972 team.

32 of 57

26. 2008 New York Giants

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (32)

Chris McGrath/Getty Images

The '08 Giants were better than their Super Bowl XLII team. Despite Osi Umenyiora missing the season, the Giants deployed a top-five defense. They also ranked third in points scored and had two 1,000-yard rushers in Brandon Jacobs and Derrick Ward. New York beat all four of 2008's conference championship teams — the Ravens, Steelers, Eagles and Cardinals —and the 12-win Panthers. However, the Plaxico Burress November gunshot incident wounded the Giants as well. They were 10-1 when that happened but finished 12-4. The Eagles upset them in Round 2, denying a loaded New York team a chance to host an NFC title game for the first time since 2000.

33 of 57

25. 2017 New England Patriots

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (33)

Brad Rempel-USA TODAY Sports

An early appearance on this list for a Super Bowl team, but New England reaching Super Bowl LII was more about favorable circ*mstances than pure dominance. A down AFC and lower-tier QBs residing on the 13-3 Pats' January docket paved one of the coziest roads a Super Bowl entrant has traveled. New England's playoff QB docket: Marcus Mariota, Blake Bortles, Nick Foles. This came after a controversial win in Pittsburgh lifted New England to the AFC's top seed. MVP Tom Brady and All-Pro Rob Gronkowski carried this squad and nearly compensated for the odd Malcolm Butler benching in a shootout Super Bowl loss.

34 of 57

24. 2015 New England Patriots

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (34)

Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports

New England's 2015 team (12-4) graded exactly the same in DVOA as its 2017 squad did (22.6 — tied for 10th-best of the Belichick era). This one zoomed to a 10-0 record and gave one of the greatest defenses in NFL history all it could handle in a 20-18 AFC championship game loss. This team had it fairly easy in the regular season, playing one 10-win team and losing (the Broncos won 30-24 in a Brock Osweiler start). But Brady and Gronkowski were atop their games in 2015. And by pushing the eventual champion Broncos — home underdogs in that championship game — to the limit, the Pats proved again they were the era's toughest playoff out.

35 of 57

23. 1995 San Francisco 49ers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (35)

Jeff Haynes-Getty Images

Although the Cowboys prevailed for '90s supremacy, the 49ers ended the era's defining rivalry by beating their nemeses three straight times. They routed the 1995 Super Bowl champs with Elvis Grbac in for reigning MVP Steve Young, led the league in scoring and sported the NFL's second-best defense (coordinated by Pete Carroll). The 49ers (plus-199) went 11-5, but those losses came by a combined 15 points. A Week 17 loss in Atlanta denied San Francisco home-field advantage. The Packers did not allow the 49ers to reach a fourth straight NFC title game, dominating in a divisional-round win. The Packers and 49ers met in each of the ensuing three postseasons.

36 of 57

22. 1977 Oakland Raiders

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (36)

Focus on Sport-Getty Images

These Raiders came close to back-to-back Super Bowl appearances. Fueled by a career year from fullback Mark Van Eeghen (1,273 yards), the Raiders started 8-1. The one blemish in that stretch forced them to leave the Bay Area for the AFC championship game. The 12-2 Broncos beat the 11-3 Raiders in Oakland in Week 5 and held on for a 20-17 AFC title game win in frigid Denver, aided by a questionable forward-progress call that negated a Raiders fumble recovery. This came a week after Oakland's double-overtime "Ghost to the Post" triumph in Baltimore, which ended up being John Madden and Ken Stabler's final playoff win.

37 of 57

21. 1974 Miami Dolphins

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (37)

Michael Zagaris-Getty Images

The AFC in the 1970s featured three superpowers. The best game between two of them occurred in 1974. Gunning for a third straight Super Bowl title and fourth consecutive Super Bowl, the 1974 Dolphins finished 11-3 and were top six on offense and defense. Paul Warfield and Nat Moore helped a ground game that was a cut below previous Miami attacks, thanks to an early-season Mercury Morris injury. Both Dolphin wideouts scored touchdowns against the Raiders in the playoffs. But Oakland prevailed 28-26 in the "Sea of Hands" divisional-round game, with Clarence Davis' game-winning TD ousting the Dolphins and ending the greatest run in franchise history.

38 of 57

20. 1994 Dallas Cowboys

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (38)

Anacleto Rapping-Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

In a unique period where a Cowboys-49ers arms race hovered on a competitive plane above the rest of the NFL, the two-time reigning champs parted ways with Jimmy Johnson. Barry Switzer's first Cowboys team (12-4) was still so talented it marched to the precipice of a three-peat. Dallas' offense scored the NFL's second-most points; its defense allowed the third-fewest. But the 49ers, retooled with a Deion Sanders-led free agent armada assembled to beat the Cowboys, defeated their rivals twice in 1994 en route to a Super Bowl blowout. A disputed Sanders pass interference no-call helped end Dallas' comeback hopes in a 38-28 loss.

39 of 57

19. 2011 Green Bay Packers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (39)

Jamie Squire-Getty Images

The only team to go 15-1 and fail to win a playoff game, these Packers fielded a much better squad in their Super Bowl title defense than the 10-6 team that became champion. Helping the Packers to the NFL's fourth-highest single-season point total (560), MVP Aaron Rodgers set a still-standing passer rating record (122.5) and finished with a 45-6 TD-INT ratio. Green Bay's defense, however, ranked just 19th. In a harbinger of things to come for the Rodgers-era Packers, the team's defensive issues burned this squad against a surging Giants team. Hakeem Nicks' apex afternoon ended in a 37-20 Giants divisional-round rout at Lambeau Field.

40 of 57

18. 2007 Indianapolis Colts

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (40)

Streeter Lecka-Getty Images

The sports world received four Peyton Manning-Tom Brady AFC championship game matchups but was deprived of the best possible duel. The unbeaten Patriots awaited, but the Chargers upset the 13-3 Colts — who saw two dropped passes turn into INTs on a three-turnover day — in the divisional round. The Patriots beat the Colts 24-20 in the regular season, but that year's AFC No. 2 seed started 13-2 before resting starters in Week 17. Indianapolis ranked third in offense and first defensively. These Colts had a better point differential (plus-188) than the 2006 and '09 Super Bowl entrants did. A wounded Bolts team lost to the Pats a week later.

41 of 57

17. 2020 Kansas City Chiefs

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (41)

Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports

The runaway AFC favorite redeployed a terrifying passing attack. Patrick Mahomes continued his historic pace and found Tyreek Hill and Travis Kelce for a combined 26 TDs, with Kelce shattering the single-season tight end yardage record in just 15 games. The Chiefs went a franchise-best 14-2 but kept inferior competition in games, sporting a plus-111 differential (only 14th-best in team annals). An order-restoring AFC title game romp over the Bills proved costly, with the Chiefs losing left tackle Eric Fisher. The Bucs preyed on a Chiefs team down both tackles, handing Mahomes his first blowout loss. This was the sixth defending champion to lose a Super Bowl; the Chiefs are now also the second team to venture to four in five years.

42 of 57

16. 1983 Washington

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (42)

Focus on Sport-Getty Images

The 2013 Broncos hold the single-season scoring record; the '07 Patriots held it for six years. The '98 Vikings, the pre-Pats record holders, chased a team that presided atop the points list for 15 years. Washington's 1983 outfit went 14-2, scored 541 points, saw Joe Theismann win MVP and a 34-year-old John Riggins rush for a then-record 24 TDs. Washington nearly blew a 21-point lead against San Francisco in the NFC title game and received some friendly officiating in a 24-21 win. Washington had beaten the Raiders in a Week 5 shootout, but Los Angeles' 38-9 drubbing in Super Bowl XVIII diminishes this team's place in history.

43 of 57

15. 1978 Dallas Cowboys

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (43)

Ross Lewis-Getty Images

Known mostly for Jackie Smith's touchdown drop and Thomas "Hollywood" Henderson's entrance into the bulletin board-material pantheon, the '78 Cowboys (12-4) were one of the decade's best teams. Headlined by first-team All-Pros Randy White and Cliff Harris, nine Pro Bowlers came from this roster. This was also Tony Dorsett's breakout year (1,703 scrimmage yards). The Cowboys crushed the Rams, 28-0, in the NFC title game and nearly rallied after Smith's drop in Super Bowl XIII, but the Steelers' 35-31 win entrenched them as the 1970s' premier team.

44 of 57

14. 1986 Chicago Bears

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (44)

Jonathan Daniel-Getty Images

While the 1985 Bears are maybe the NFL's most celebrated team, the '86 defense was statistically superior. It yielded 11.7 points per game (down from 12.4 in '85) and, led by All-Pros Mike Singletary and Wilber Marshall, housed four Pro Bowlers. However, a Packers defender altered Bears history. Charles Martin's horrifying late hit on Jim McMahon knocked Chicago's starter out for the season in November. Mike Ditka turned to three other QBs, lastly an overmatched Doug Flutie. Washington ousted the QB-limited Bears (14-2; 6-0 with McMahon) in the divisional round, with Flutie going just 11-for-31 in the 27-13 loss. The '86 Bears are a quality NFL "what if?" story.

45 of 57

13. 2014 Seattle Seahawks

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (45)

Robert Deutsch-USA TODAY Sports

It is hard to come up with a sequence that made a bigger impact on two teams' trajectories than Malcolm Butler's interception in Super Bowl XLIX. These Seahawks (12-4) were not as good as the 2013 squad, losing to three non-playoff teams, and suffering a slew of defensive injuries in the playoffs. But the No. 1 defense helped Seattle lock in with a six-game win streak to close the regular season. And the Seahawks rallied from 16 points down in the NFC championship game. In Marshawn Lynch's last great year (17 TDs, 1,672 yards from scrimmage), OC Darrell Bevell's fateful play call likely denied Seahawks a title. Seattle players criticized the decision, and it began the final leg of the Patriot dynasty.

46 of 57

12. 1990 San Francisco 49ers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (46)

Otto Greule Jr.-Getty Images

These 49ers still rostered all-time greats in Joe Montana, Jerry Rice, Ronnie Lott and Charles Haley. Montana won his second straight MVP, Rice was amid an astonishing 10 All-Pros-in-11-seasons run, and the 49ers closed out a record-setting 18-game road win streak in a 14-2 season. This was not the best 49ers team; its offense ranked just eighth in 1990. But it was the toughest out among Super Bowl-era threepeat pursuers. A Montana injury in the NFC title game opened the door to a 15-13 Giants upset. The 49ers' dominance lasted several more years, but Leonard Marshall's hit marked Montana's last relevant action in San Francisco.

47 of 57

11. 1997 Green Bay Packers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (47)

Kevin Reece-Getty Images

While not quite as good as their stacked predecessor, the 1997 Packers rolled to a second straight 13-3 season. Brett Favre won a third consecutive MVP — the only player to do so — and helped Green Bay notch seven wins over playoff-bound teams and stampede through the NFC playoffs. After winning a stacked NFC Central, the No. 2-seeded Packers outscored the Bucs and 49ers 44-17 en route to Super Bowl XXXII and were 11-point favorites over the Broncos once there. Denver's zone-blocking scheme gashed Green Bay's defense in a 31-24 upset, but the Packers traded scores until the end.

48 of 57

10. 2023 Kansas City Chiefs

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (48)

Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports

Reminding of the 1988 49ers, a six-loss team that caught fire thanks to a legendary HC-QB combination and a sneaky-elite defense, these Chiefs will be hard to rank historically. They submitted such an uneven regular season, which featured losses to the Broncos and Raiders and a 1-4 record against playoff teams, they lose ground when compared to the best of the best. Kansas City finished with a plus-77 point differential, and while the team awakened in the playoffs, its final three wins —granted, over top competition —came by a combined 13 points. That said, pairing a No. 2-ranked defense with Patrick Mahomes —even a less dominant version of the QB —presented scary assignments for January and February foes.

49 of 57

9. 1967 Green Bay Packers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (49)

Bettmann/Getty Images

This may have been the weakest of Vince Lombardi's five Packers championship squads, but his veteran bunch won arguably the most iconic game in league history and thrashed the AFL's Raiders 33-14 in Super Bowl II. Having moved on from its famed Jim Taylor-Paul Hornung ground attack, Green Bay went 9-4-1. Led by Bart Starr and a host of Hall of Famers, the Packers still routed the 11-1-2 Rams in the NFL semis and mounted a 68-yard drive to derail the Cowboys, 21-17, in the "Ice Bowl." This doubled as the end for the aging nucleus' playoff access, but the Packers are the only team to threepeat in the playoff era (1934-present).

50 of 57

8. 1979 Pittsburgh Steelers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (50)

Robert Riger/Getty Images

The last of the Steelers' 1970s Super Bowl triumphs was geared more around offense, which made sense after a Steelers-induced rule change helped passing attacks. Of the four Chuck Noll title teams, this 12-4 squad scored the most points (416, a franchise record until 2014). It allowed the most of the championship teams, too, but Terry Bradshaw and John Stallworth (1,183 receiving yards) compensated for the slight Steel Curtain slippage. The Steelers blew out the Dolphins before catching an officiating break against the Oilers. Bradshaw threw for 309 yards and two TDs in his Super Bowl swan song, a 31-19 win over the Rams.

51 of 57

7. 1976 Pittsburgh Steelers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (51)

Focus on Sport-Getty Images

After a 1-4 start, the Steelers won nine straight games behind the most dominant defensive stretch in NFL history. In those nine games, the Steel Curtain allowed two touchdowns. Two. Joe Greene, Mel Blount and Co. pitched five shutouts and permitted only field goals in three other games. The Steelers bulldozed the Colts 40-14 but lost 1,000-yard rushers Franco Harris and Rocky Bleier during the divisional-round win. The Raiders ended the run with a 24-7 victory to squash the Steelers' three-peat hopes. At 9.9 points allowed per game (3.1 during the streak), this was a signature stretch of football regardless of the threepeat bid's 11th-hour ending.

52 of 57

6. 1993 Dallas Cowboys

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (52)

Focus on Sport-Getty Images

Missing Emmitt Smith due to a holdout, the Cowboys started 0-2. They rebounded to go 12-4 and claim a repeat championship. Smith returned in Week 3 and, headlined by his separated-shoulder Week 18 showing (229 scrimmage yards in an OT win over the Giants that clinched the Cowboys home-field advantage), earned NFL MVP acclaim. Still buoyed by 1989's Herschel Walker trade, the Cowboys ranked second on offense and defense and dominated the 49ers in the most one-sided of the Cowboys-49ers 1990s NFC title games. The Bills rematch ended in another clear victory, but Jimmy Johnson's ensuing exit altered the Cowboys' path.

53 of 57

5. 2004 New England Patriots

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (53)

Andy Lyons-Getty Images

The Patriots' super-high-floor 2010s work notwithstanding, the best Pats stretch occurred in the mid-2000s. This era crested in 2004, when the Patriots finished off an NFL-record 18-game regular-season win streak and went 14-2. Corey Dillon rushed for a career-high 1,645 yards, and New England's stout defense ranked second in points ceded. Peyton Manning's supercharged Colts offense scored just three points in the Patriot defense's divisional-round masterpiece, and the Pats were not seriously threatened by the Steelers or Eagles going forward. Although Spygate will be attached to this team, the on-field product was nearly flawless.

54 of 57

4. 1998 Denver Broncos

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (54)

Allen Kee-Getty Images

No NFLer amassed more scrimmage yards in a season than Terrell Davis in the 1998 Broncos' 19 games (2,762). Denver (14-2) beat 12 opponents by double digits, started 13-0 and outscored playoff opposition 95-32. John Elway missed four games, but Bubby Brister kept the ship on course via a 4-0 Elway-less stretch. Rod Smith and Ed McCaffrey surpassed 1,000 receiving yards, and Shannon Sharpe scored 10 TDs. Miami beat Denver by double digits that December but lost 38-3 in the divisional round. The Broncos, better than their '97 champion, led the Falcons 31-6 at one point in Super Bowl XXXIII and cruised to a repeat title in Elway's finale.

55 of 57

3. 1975 Pittsburgh Steelers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (55)

Getty Images

The 1979 Steelers offense was far better; the '76 team submitted supreme NFL defense. This title-defense season went through the best set of opponents and revealed dynasty potential. Franco Harris ran for 1,246 yards, Lynn Swann made his first Pro Bowl, and the Steel Curtain was wire-to-wire great in a 12-2 season. Pittsburgh allowed 11.6 points per game, outscored opposition by a team-record 211 points and limited the Colts and Raiders to 10 apiece in the AFC bracket. Swann came through with, impact-wise, the greatest wideout showing in Super Bowl history. The second-year wideout's acrobatics lifted the Steelers to a 21-17 win over the Cowboys in Super Bowl X.

56 of 57

2. 1973 Miami Dolphins

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (56)

Focus on Sport-Getty Images

This is the best Dolphins team ever assembled. The 1972 version won all its games but beat just two winning teams in the regular season and did not face a playoff-bound opponent during the slate. Miami in '73 (12-2) beat three playoff-bound squads and after Super Bowl VIII had defeated the four other premier 1970s franchises -- Pittsburgh, Oakland, Dallas and Minnesota. Pro Bowlers Larry Csonka and Mercury Morris both eclipsed 950 rushing yards in 14 games, and Paul Warfield caught 11 TD passes. No playoff opponent came within two touchdowns of the Dolphins, and Bob Griese needed to throw only seven passes in a dominant 24-7 Super Bowl win over the Vikings.

57 of 57

1. 1989 San Francisco 49ers

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (57)

Focus on Sport-Getty Images

Joe Montana's QB GOAT case starts here. At the peak of his powers at age 33, the 49ers icon was on his own tier in 1989. His completion percentage (70.2), yards per attempt (9.1) and passer rating (112.4) look confusing when compared to his peers. Roger Craig, John Taylor and apex Jerry Rice (17 TDs) made 1989 the West Coast Offense's masterwork, despite Bill Walsh having retired after the '88 season. San Francisco's defense ranked third, too. The 49ers went 14-2, losing by five total points, and obliterated the Vikings, Rams and Broncos by a 126-26 margin in the playoffs. George Seifert's debut team may be the NFL's best ever.

Sam Robinson is a Kansas City, Mo.-based writer who mostly writes about the NFL. He has covered sports for nearly 10 years. Boxing, the Royals and Pandora stations featuring female rock protagonists are some of his go-tos. Occasionally interesting tweets @SRobinson25.

Ranking every Super Bowl champion's title defense (2024)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Golda Nolan II

Last Updated:

Views: 5972

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (58 voted)

Reviews: 89% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Golda Nolan II

Birthday: 1998-05-14

Address: Suite 369 9754 Roberts Pines, West Benitaburgh, NM 69180-7958

Phone: +522993866487

Job: Sales Executive

Hobby: Worldbuilding, Shopping, Quilting, Cooking, Homebrewing, Leather crafting, Pet

Introduction: My name is Golda Nolan II, I am a thoughtful, clever, cute, jolly, brave, powerful, splendid person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.